The Thirteenth Tale (book review) - May have spoilers
http://www.pregnancy.org/bulletinboards/showthread.php?t=280020
I posted the review on my book club board:
Ok... so I finally finished the book. The Thirteenth Tale by Diane Setterfield. I have to say that it went VERY slow for me and the only reason I continued on was because a couple people said it was good and I had to know why. I also wanted to comprehend what the book was about.
For me it finally semi picked up around page 190. Then the last 3-4 chapters a bit more but never to a point I could say OH this is worth it. I know I have alot of personal issues due to my past - but one thing that bothered me was the incestuous issues throughout the book. I understand bondings - but when it runs into incestuousness I cannot stomach it. (She did a fantastic job of no swearing or even any inappropriate scenes - which I am more than grateful for!)
Then to make twins more than they are by bringing them into this sick bond made me sad... I find twins and multiples to be a beautiful thing. I think this book made it almost Ugly. Being a mother of mult.s (opposite sex) it really bothered me even deeper than I think it would have if I just read it as a story without personalizing it.
There is a dark and mysteriousness to the book (a bit on the Gothic side.) However, I find that the author is very long winded - making the book drag on FOREVER.
In the end - I do not recommend the book. I give it 4 thumbs down - but if anyone wants it email me and let me know. This will not be one I keep in my library.
I posted the review on my book club board:
Ok... so I finally finished the book. The Thirteenth Tale by Diane Setterfield. I have to say that it went VERY slow for me and the only reason I continued on was because a couple people said it was good and I had to know why. I also wanted to comprehend what the book was about.
For me it finally semi picked up around page 190. Then the last 3-4 chapters a bit more but never to a point I could say OH this is worth it. I know I have alot of personal issues due to my past - but one thing that bothered me was the incestuous issues throughout the book. I understand bondings - but when it runs into incestuousness I cannot stomach it. (She did a fantastic job of no swearing or even any inappropriate scenes - which I am more than grateful for!)
Then to make twins more than they are by bringing them into this sick bond made me sad... I find twins and multiples to be a beautiful thing. I think this book made it almost Ugly. Being a mother of mult.s (opposite sex) it really bothered me even deeper than I think it would have if I just read it as a story without personalizing it.
There is a dark and mysteriousness to the book (a bit on the Gothic side.) However, I find that the author is very long winded - making the book drag on FOREVER.
In the end - I do not recommend the book. I give it 4 thumbs down - but if anyone wants it email me and let me know. This will not be one I keep in my library.
2 comments:
I hadn't heard of it and wasn't planning on reading it, but it's still good to know in case it should happen to come up. Thank you for your info. I don't think I would like it either from the description you gave. You gotta wonder why others recommended it. Thanks! :-)
I won't be reading that one. I'm sorry if it brought back the pain.
Post a Comment